Questions And Answers On 15/07 Feto Coup Attempt And Human Rights In Turkey

Beyrut Büyükelçiliği 26.08.2016

1. What is a “State of Emergency”?

State of Emergency is a measure permitted by the Turkish Constitution and regulated by relevant national legislation. The Constitution includes explicit provisions on the State of Emergency and provides necessary safeguards through setting out clear conditions, rules and procedures for the declaration of the State of Emergency as well as the general principles to be observed during the State of Emergency.

State of Emergency is also a practice permissible under international human rights law, including European Convention on Human Rights. Article 15 of the ECHR provides the Member States with the right to take measures derogating from their obligations under the Convention, in public emergency situations.

2. When did the Turkish Government declared “State of Emergency”?

In order to fight effectively against the Fethullah Gülen Teror Organization (FETO) which poses a grave threat to the survival and security of Turkey through its clandestine infiltration to state mechanisms, the Council of Ministers of Turkey decided on 20 July 2016 that a nationwide state of emergency be declared as from July 21, 2016 for a period of ninety days, pursuant to Article 120 of the Constitution and Article 3 § 1 (b) of the Law on the State of Emergency (Law no. 2935).

3. What is the purpose of “State of Emergency”?

This decision was taken upon the recommendation of the National Security Council and later on endorsed by the Turkish Parliament on 21 July 2016.

The purpose of the State of Emergency is to take required measures in the most speedy and effective manner in the fight against FETO terrorist organization in order to safeguard our nation from this raving terror network and return to normalcy as soon as possible.

In this process, utmost care will continue to be shown to uphold our democracy and the fundamental rights of our citizens within the rule of law, as always.

4. Is there any other country recently resorted to this measure?

Turkey is not the only country who resorted to declare State of Emergency in such circumstances. Many democratic countries did the same when facing similar or even against limited security threats. France, a member of the EU and the Council of Europe (CoE), also declared State of Emergency on 14th November 2015 and has extended it until the end of January 2017.

5. Why Turkey did not declare “State of Emergency” before?

The gravity and magnitude of the 15 July 2016 coup attempt deemed this measure necessary. It is true that before 15 July, the Turkish government carried out its counter-terror operations against PKK and DAESH terrorist organizations in severe conditions without declaring a State of Emergency.

Yet, in the face of FETO terrorist military coup attempt against the national security and this terrorist organization’s infiltration into the state organs as well as in several sectors, both in public and private, such as health, education, academia, business etc, the declaration of the State of Emergency had to be resorted to eradicate this terrorist network in these structures in a most speedy and effective manner.

6. Will State of Emergency affect Turkey’s adherence to democracy and observance of fundamental rights and freedoms?

The Republic of Turkey is fully aware of its obligations related to democracy, human rights, the principle of rule of law and international conventions in this process and as in the past, due respect will be shown to fundamental rights and freedoms and the principle of supremacy of law will be strictly observed.

Although the State of Emergency has been declared for a period of 90 days, all extraordinary measures will be terminated once the result in the fight against the FETO terrorist organization is successfully attained.

As clearly stated by Foreign Minister Mevlüt Çavuşoğlu in his article published in Newsweek recently, we are determined to fight these enemies of our democracy with democracy. Turkey as one of the founding members of the Council of Europe, which represents the most advanced standards and norms in democracy, human rights and the rule of law, has the necessary will and assets to do so. What we need from our friends, partners and allies is solidarity, understanding as well as constructive cooperation in this process.

7. What is the role of the Turkish people in averting the coup attempt?

The democratic resolve of the Turkish society together with the state has saved the democratic regime against this terrorist campaign. The Turkish people coming from all segments of life and regardless of their political affiliations took to the streets on the night of 15th of July. The political parties did the same in defending democracy at the parliament against the bombs. This democratic spirit creates a remarkable unity and a new political consensus for further strengthening of democracy in Turkey.

8. Does the coup attempt and the State of Emergency affected the reform process for further democratization of Turkey?

While resolutely fighting the FETÖ under state of emergency, the Government is now also taking concrete steps to further the reform process in the field of human rights, rule of law and democracy as manifested in the ongoing works for constitutional reform. This process has gained impetus as the political parties at the Parliament joined the efforts in a constructive manner.

9. What are the repercussions of derogations in accordance with Article 15 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and Article 4 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR)?

Once the declaration of State of Emergency was declared, Turkey duly
resorted to the right of derogation from the obligations in the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).

Indeed, relevant articles of these Conventions (Article 15 of the ECHR and Article 4 of the ICCPR) permit the Contracting Parties to take measures derogating from their obligations under the Conventions in extraordinary circumstances.

A derogation is not a suspension of rights. It may bring certain limitations to the exercise of certain rights under required conditions.

These provisions allow States to take necessary measures without delay for the protection of human rights in cases of emergency threatening the life of the nation.

Many countries have also made use of this flexibility allowed by the ECHR and ICCPR.

Currently, France has declared that it may restrict its obligations under both international conventions.

10. What are the legal measures taken by Turkey after the coup attempt?

The Public Prosecutors are investigating the severe crimes committed by the coup plotters on 15th July, as well as those who are linked to the FETO (Gülenist Teror Organization). However, these investigations are limited to those who supported the FETO during or before the coup plot.

In the face of the tragic events unfolded on 15th July, judicial authorities carry out all necessary legal measures to disclose any support to the bloody coup. There can be no exemption from the criminal investigations and the related measures.

The rule of law is guaranteed by Constitution. Turkey is party to major international conventions on human rights, in particular the European Convention on Human Rights. Ongoing investigations and prosecutions are undertaken by the independent judiciary. Rights of suspects are under protection within the limits of the State of Emergency.

11. What about the investigations vis a vis judges and prosecutors?

The judges and prosecutors who are being investigated have been suspended from office on the grounds of the existence of strong criminal suspicion for their involvement in the alleged offences.

The Inspection Board of the High Council of Judges and Prosecutors took this decision with a view to protecting the investigations from any possible influence as well as ensuring the credibility of the judiciary.

Indeed the relevant authorities had been investigating FETO even before the foiled coup attempt. Fabricating evidence in the investigations related to Ergenekon and Balyoz cases, as well as the military espionage case initiated thereafter had already been linked to some FETO members within the judiciary.

The investigations initiated in respect of the suspects are in progress.

Proceedings are being carried out in accordance with our legislation and our international obligations.

12. What about the investigations about journalists?

On 15th July the terrorist coup plotters raided major press/media establishments, both state and private ones, and forced these media organs to spread their illegal messages. They also attacked satellite control centers in order to cut TV broadcasting all around the country. Therefore, it is evident that independent press and media organizations were among the primary targets of the terrorists.

However, their attempt to control the media did not last long and they faced a solid resistance especially from the private media organs. Under this critical environment, free and pluralistic Turkish media played a vital role in the prevention of the coup attempt as a deterrent force against the plotters.

The Public Prosecutors are investigating these severe crimes committed by the coup plotters as well as those who are linked to FETO. Within this framework, a number of journalists are also being investigated. However, these investigations are limited to those who supported the FETO terrorist organization during or before the coup plot.

It is clear that the alleged acts attributed to these people, if proven, cannot be considered within journalistic work. In the face of the tragic events unfolded on 15th July, judicial authorities consider it worthwhile to prosecute any support to the bloody coup, regardless of the profession of the supporters as such acts constitute crime.

The work of journalism does not provide these people exemption from the criminal investigations and the related measures.

If ruled guilty by the courts in due judicial process they would be naturally convicted not because of their profession as journalist, but because they used their profession in the service of committing crimes in respect of terrorist coup attempt and/or being linked to the FETO terrorist organization.

In fact, judicial authorities had been investigating a number of journalists even before the foiled coup attempt. The charges included fabricating false evidence for the investigations of the Ergenekon case and other publicly renowned cases, as well as similar illegal acts in the service of the FETO terrorist organization.

The rule of law is guaranteed by our Constitution. Our country is party to major international conventions on human rights, in particular the European Convention on Human Rights. Ongoing investigations and prosecutions are undertaken by the independent judiciary.

Rights of all suspects are under protection in accordance with the rules of the state of emergency as permitted by the constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights.

13. What about the closure of media institutions after coup attempt?

In accordance with the Decree dated 27 July 2016 (No. 668), private-run radio and television institutions, newspaper, magazine, publishing companies and distribution channels which belong to, connect to, or contact with the Fetullah Gülen Terrorist Organization (FETO), which pose a threat to the national security, have been closed down.

Majority of these establishments were subject to criminal investigations prior to the terrorist coup attempt and legal sanctions were taken for many. In the context of the said investigations, a number of Criminal Magistrates’ Offices indicated that those press and media organizations made publications by order of the founder and the executives of the FETO in order to achieve illegal goals of the organization.

Many companies were also charged with carrying out false transactions aimed at financing a terrorist organization concealing the financial resources of the organization and transferring funds abroad.

14. And the closure of certain private education institutions?

In accordance with the Decree dated 23 July 2016 (No. 667), legal private entities which belong to, connected to, or contact with the FETO, which pose a threat to the national security, have been dissolved.

In this context, a number of private education institutions, including universities have been closed down.

With a view to protecting the right to education, it has been prescribed that students registered in those institutions shall be placed at other universities by the Council of Higher Education.

For the academics and other personnel that worked at those institutions, the Council of Ministers is entitled to establish the procedure and principles concerning their transfer to other institutions. Thus necessary measures will be taken in order to protect their right to work and other ensuing rights.

15. What do you think of the allegations of torture and human rights violations in Turkey after the coup attempt?

We strongly reject groundless allegations that question our commitment to eliminate all acts of torture or inhuman treatment.

Turkey is party to both the UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment since 1988 and the European Convention For the Prevention of Torture and Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment since 1989. Turkey has a constructive cooperation with their respective international monitoring organs namely UN Committee Against Torture and European Committee For the Prevention of Torture.

Turkey is also party to UN Optional Protocol to the Convention Against Torture (OPCAT) and designated Human Rights and Equality Institution as the National Prevention Mechanism accordingly.

Our Government has adopted a “zero tolerance policy against torture” back in 2003 and in line with this policy, relevant measures have been continuously taken.

The success of the reforms achieved in relation to the relevant legislation were acknowledged by the European Committee for the Prevention of Torture as early as 2004.

Moreover, the statute of limitations with regard to the offence of torture, was fully abolished in 2013, thus enabling more effective investigation. This is a ground-breaking development under the scope of the zero tolerance policy against torture.

Turkey’s full commitment to take effective legislative, administrative, judicial and other measures to prevent acts of torture, as defined in the Conventions to which Turkey is a party, continue unabated.

The Republic of Turkey firmly upholds the principle of the rule of law. Despite the extraordinary circumstances our nation has gone through, arrest and detention procedures are being conducted in accordance with the national legislation that is compatible with international human rights standards.

16. What is your view on the claims raised by Amnesty International dated July 24th?

Turkish Ministry of Justice has issued a statement on 25th July, rejecting those allegations. And clarifying that such claims are baseless.

We would have expected these human rights NGOs to equally uphold principles of democracy and the rule of law, by openly condemning raving atrocities committed against our democratic institutions and the constitutional order along with civilian people.

Statements starting with a few sentences of condemnation against the coup and then continuing with pages of homework for coup plotters’ human rights do not make sense for our public due to their insufficient emphasis on Turkish people’s great struggle for defending its democracy.

Presidency of our Republic was attacked, our Parliament was bombed, our citizens were crashed under the tanks and subjected to barbaric attacks, whereas press/media establishments were raided. The terrorist plotters also attempted to assassinate our President.

Statements and comments, ignoring all this violence and perpetrated crimes against our common values of the civilized world, constitute a blatant bias and prejudice.

In that regard, we cannot accept these speculative comments and unfounded allegations.

We attach importance to transparency in our measures. Recently the Ministries of Justice and Interior have met with representatives of AI to explain the measures and exchanged views with them in a frank manner.

17. Will death penalty be reintroduced in Turkey?

Despite the numerous terrorist attacks that we have endured in the past, our country has never compromised the standards of democracy and human rights. We will continue to strongly uphold these standards.

Capital punishment was long removed from the domestic legislation. Similarly, Turkey is party to relevant international instruments concerning the abolition of the death penalty.

We are fully aware of our international obligations as well as the existing national legislation.

On 15 July, the Presidency of our Republic was attacked, our Parliament was bombed, our citizens were crashed under the tanks and subjected to barbaric attacks, and press/media establishments were raided.

Faced with such raving atrocity, the expectation for reinstating the death penalty, as voiced by the people should be seen as a reflection of the strong reaction they have felt against these treasonous crimes.

This will naturally be assessed prudently, in its due course, through all possible channels including the Parliament.

Conclusions of the democratic debate that can be carried at a time ripe, shall be decisive


Hakan Çakıl Ambassador
Monday - Friday

09:00 - 16:00 / Kon. 09:00 - 14:00

1/1/2018 1/1/2018 New Year
1/6/2018 1/6/2018 Armenian Orthodox Christmas Day
2/9/2018 2/9/2018 St Maroun Day
2/14/2018 2/14/2018 Rafiq Hariri Memorial Day
3/25/2018 3/25/2018 Feast of Annunciation
3/30/2018 3/30/2018 Good Friday (Western Church)
4/1/2018 4/2/2018 Easter Sunday
4/6/2018 4/6/2018 Holy Friday (Orthodox Church)
5/1/2018 5/1/2018 Labor Day
5/6/2018 5/6/2018 Martyr's Day
5/25/2018 5/25/2018 Resistance and Liberation Day
6/15/2018 6/16/2018 Eid Al-Fitr (Ramadan)
8/15/2018 8/15/2018 Assumption of Mary
8/21/2018 8/22/2018 Aid Al-Adha (Date varies according to Lunar cycle)
9/11/2018 9/11/2018 Hijri New Year
9/20/2018 9/20/2018 Ashoura Day
11/20/2018 11/20/2018 The Birth of Prophet Mohammed
11/22/2018 11/22/2018 Independence Day
12/25/2018 12/25/2018 Christmas Day